top of page

Who Is to Blame for Our Environmental Issues?

Jordan Parker
23 minutes ago
3 min read
Woman emotionally points to camera

No problem humans have faced is as challenging and massive as the climate crisis. Collectively, humans are destroying the planet's ability to support life; this is known as the Holocene extinction, which we are all currently living in. Whether it’s what to do with our household garbage or large-scale deforestation and pollution from global corporations, we all struggle with “who is to blame." If we assign blame for our environmental issues, we can then pass off the responsibility for creating solutions to someone else. But what if we all have some responsibility? It’s impossible to be a living being without consuming resources and creating waste. The question we should all be asking ourselves is not “Who is to blame?” but “What’s my role?”


There’s a false dichotomy between corporate 'polluters' and individual 'polluters'. And there’s another false dichotomy between billionaires and high-net worth individuals and the bottom 90% of income earners. You’ll often hear the rhetoric that we “need to make polluters pay” in environmental circles. This is a call for giant corporations like ExxonMobile, Phillip Morris, or Coca-Cola - for example - to care about more than just profits and consider factors like human health, environmental protection and social justice in their business practices. It demands that massive corporations pay for the downstream consequences of their products and invest in business models that result in less damage in the first place.


On the other hand, in industry circles you’ll hear rhetoric that corporations are “just meeting market demand” and “providing services, products and conveniences” that make everyday life better for people. If people don’t want plastic bags, they should simply stop using them. If consumers don’t want fossil fuel pollution, they should stop buying cars that run on gas. If there’s too much fast fashion, stop the constant stream of Amazon packages delivered to your door. Don’t come after the manufacturers who are "just giving consumers what they want."


In other circles you’ll hear people complaining about the ultra-rich luxuriating in their private jets and super-yachts. If one billionaire can emit as much carbon in 90 minutes as one average person can in their entire lifetime, isn’t it laughable to think that one person choosing to use a reusable bag rather than single-use plastic or taking mass transit as opposed to driving would ever make a difference?


But what if, when we ask “Who should take responsibility,” the answer is, “All of the above”? We should be talking about concepts such as “ethical capitalism” and how government is a critical check-and-balance in the evolution of our economic system. We should also be talking about the impact of individual actions that add up to collective problems. While one billionaire’s consumption dwarfs that of the average person, many of our biggest environmental issues result from the small, seemingly insignificant behaviors that billions of people engage in every day: one plastic bag, one bottle of water, one meal thrown in the garbage, and one piece of clothing ordered from SHEIN at a time. Multiplied by billions of people every day, these collective problems dwarf the impact of one billionaire. Even all of the approximate 3000 billionaires in the world would never use as many single-use plastic bags as the other 8.3 billion people collectively use every day.


Globally, every second a garbage truck full of fast fashion and textile waste is dumped - either in a landfill or an ocean - or is burned. Locally, in the city of Chicago, consumers still use and discard 514 single-use paper and plastic bags every single minute (which is 73% below the national average). In Illinois, 13 semi-trucks full of food waste head to a landfill every hour.


But these collective actions can also add up to big solutions. What if we had a more robust food donation system that made it easier to donate edible food for either human or animal consumption, so that we could waste less? What if we had more composting infrastructure to keep food scrap waste out of landfills and valuable nutrients in circulation? What if we used policy to move individuals and industry towards more ethical consumption and capitalism? Feed & Conserve Illinois was created to do exactly this.


We all just experienced our democracy at work in the recent Midterm elections. One vote doesn’t shift an entire election, but millions of votes do. We need to start democratizing our waste the same way we democratized our political system: one vote for a healthier planet is one reusable bag, one less purchase, one rescued meal or one container of food scraps put into the compost bucket rather than the garbage. Collectively, millions of these votes placed through small, everyday actions can be the change that our world needs.

Comments


bottom of page